The 2019 USCAA Men's Soccer All-American Teams
November 8, 2019
Men's Division 1 Soccer All-Americans
| Student-Athlete | School | Year | Position |
| First Team All-Americans | |||
| Aaron Boateng | University of Maine Fort Kent | So | D |
| CONNOR MCGOLDRICK | Bryant & Stratton-Syracuse | Sr | D |
| Francisco Bongiovanni | Florida National University | Jr | D |
| Yago Pimenta | Bryant & Stratton-Syracuse | So | D |
| Travar McCulloch | University of Maine Fort Kent | Sr | F |
| Nickalous Gayle | University of Maine Fort Kent | Jr | F |
| Manuel Villegas | Florida National University | So | F |
| Yazen Bakhrebah | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | Fr. | F |
| Babucarr Ceesay | Bryant & Stratton-Syracuse | So | GK |
| Glenroy Osbourne | University of Maine Fort Kent | Sr | GK |
| Omar Abdallah Nabilsi | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | Fr. | M |
| Edson Alvarado | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | Fr. | M |
| Sebastian Mendez | Paul Quinn College | Fr | M |
| Emile Amouzou | Bryant & Stratton-Syracuse | So | M |
| Second Team All-Americans | |||
| Julio Hernandez | Paul Quinn College | Sr | D |
| Martin Marijuan | Florida National University | So | D |
| Francisco Villanueva | Washington Adventist University | So | D |
| Noah Bryant | Mid-Atlantic Christian | So | F |
| Brody Rettle | SUNY Delhi | Jr | F |
| Levyn Benavides | Paul Quinn College | Jr | F |
| Lucas Moreira | Washington Adventist University | Sr | F |
| Hunter Haugland | University of Dallas | Sr | F |
| Rodrigo Festuccia | Florida National University | JR | GK |
| Keaton Krischak | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | So. | GK |
| Daniel Moreira | Washington Adventist University | Sr | M |
| Paulo Correia | Dean College | So. | M |
| Chase Reynolds | University of Dallas | Jr | M |
| Brady McNamara | University of Dallas | Jr | M |
| Honorable Mention | |||
| Evan Luck | Bryant & Stratton College-Albany | So | D |
| Jake Buete | University of Dallas | Fr | D |
| Kyle Lamb | Bryant & Stratton College-Albany | So | F |
| Corey O'Toole | SUNY Delhi | Sr | GK |
| Nate Getman | Bryant & Stratton College-Albany | JR | GK |
| Bryce Antoch | Dean College | So. | GK |
| Juan Velez | SUNY Delhi | So | M |
| Mathurin Allawai | University of Valley Forge | Fr | M |
Men's Division 2 All-Americans
| School | Student-Athlete | Year | Position |
| First Team All-American | |||
| Penn State Brandywine | Axel Ayllon-Ortiz | Fr | D |
| Johnson & Wales - Charlotte | Ilijah Washington | So | D |
| Johnson & Wales - Charlotte | Alberto Olivas-Vazquez | So | D |
| Berkeley College NJ | Gennaro Vittorioso | Fr | D |
| Williamson College of the Trades | Patrick Kiely | Sr | F |
| Southern Maine CC | Mohamed Matan | Fy. | F |
| Berkeley College NY | Amadou Sy | So | F |
| Berkeley College NJ | Marcos Hidalgo | So | F |
| Berkeley College NY | Dario Cruz-Sepulveda | So | GK |
| Southern Maine CC | Joshua Nagle | Fy. | GK |
| Penn State Beaver | Danylo Yakymov | So | M |
| Berkeley College NY | Jean-Gardy Derineau | Jr | M |
| The King's College - NY | Edvin Loefgren | Jr | M |
| University of Cincinnati-Clermont | Jalen Hjelmeng | Jr | M |
| Second Team All-Americans | |||
| SUNY-ESF | Ian Foote | Jr. | D |
| Berkeley College NY | Benjamin Elvenes | So | D |
| Penn State Brandywine | Ian Roland | So | D |
| Penn State Beaver | Darrion Gilmore | Sr | D |
| University of Cincinnati-Clermont | TJ Manning | Fr | F |
| Penn State Beaver | Mishael Garcia | Fr | F |
| NHTI | Fiston Kapongo | Fr | F |
| Southern Maine CC | Keto Tchiputo | Fy. | F |
| Berkeley College NJ | Robert Parker | Sr. | GK |
| University of Cincinnati-Clermont | Cassidy Kelly | Fr | GK |
| Penn State New Kensington | Brady Braun | So. | M |
| Warren Wilson College | Will Feehan | Fr | M |
| Johnson & Wales - Charlotte | Jack Watters | Fr | M |
| SUNY-ESF | Mickael Myagkota | Sr. | M |
| Honorable Mention All-Americans | |||
| Penn State Hazleton | Isaac Whitenight | Sr. | D |
| Central Maine CC | Alexander Thompson | So | D |
| Berkeley College NJ | Salaimon Sarwari | JR | D |
| Penn State Brandywine | Tyler Skaer | So | D |
| Penn State Beaver | RJ Long | So | D |
| Penn State New Kensington | Carlos Colindres | Fr. | F |
| Central Penn College | Soufiane Issoufou | Fr | F |
| Christendom College | Mark LaRochelle | So | F |
| Penn State Brandywine | Alex Lopez | Fr | F |
| Five Towns College | Adrian Santos | So | F |
| SUNY-ESF | Carmine Tronolone | Jr. | GK |
| Penn State New Kensington | Joshua Zakrzewski | Sr. | GK |
| Penn State Wilkes-Barre | Ricky Wooditch | So | M |
| Five Towns College | William Rivera | Fr | M |
| Christendom | Nicholas Foeckler | So | M |
| The King's College - NY | Josiah Simons | Sr | M |
| Johnson & Wales - Charlotte | Zach Savage | Fr | M |
| Five Towns College | Adrian Wong | Fr | F |